top of page

What I Learned Helping Build Fish Welfare Initiative

Writer: Jennifer-Justine Kirsch
Jennifer-Justine Kirsch
4 minutes ago
7 min read

After 6.5 years at Fish Welfare Initiative (FWI), I am leaving the organization. In this post, I look back on helping grow FWI from 3 to 30 staff, share what I learned about leadership, hiring, and evidence, and offer broader thoughts on movement strategy.


This post may be most useful to:

  • Young people considering joining a startup charity or starting one

  • Funders and others thinking about movement strategy


Summary

  • I joined FWI after it was co-founded and helped grow it to 30 staff. I took on far more responsibility than I would likely have had in a junior role elsewhere.

  • Growth taught me that people management is mostly relationship management, and that an organization needs both a visionary and implementers.

  • We knew far less than we thought when we started, and I think this is true for the animal advocacy movement more broadly. As a movement, we likely invest too little in evidence generation and monitoring and evaluation (M&E).

  • The team and the community we built in rural India were among the best parts of the work.

  • I am leaving primarily due to personal reasons, to make space for local leadership and to apply these lessons more widely. I remain committed to working in lower-middle-income countries (LMICs).

  • Most farmed fishes live in LMICs, and progress there depends on local implementers, locally generated evidence, and clearer career paths.


Entering the Animal Advocacy Movement through FWI

I joined FWI as a generalist, and my role morphed and developed over time until I led our Programs department and the Alliance for Responsible Aquaculture (ARA), a farmer alliance that now has almost 200 farmers. I had never led an alliance or a team, worked with farmers, or worked in Asia. I had to figure it out as I went, and I made plenty of mistakes along the way.


FWI’s co-founders, Haven and Tom, and myself after-hours during one of our first weeks together.
FWI’s co-founders, Haven and Tom, and myself after-hours during one of our first weeks together.

Joining a Young Charity Supercharges Your Growth

If you have agency and don't shy away from responsibility, joining a startup charity is one of the fastest ways to grow early in your career. It is hard to get the same thing by starting in a junior role somewhere else. The responsibility forces you to upskill quickly on things you have never done, because the work needs doing and no one else is there to do it.


Here is what I picked up, much earlier than I would have elsewhere:

  • Managing people, very early on

  • Managing entire programs, with daunting autonomy and responsibility

  • Making plans and executing them

  • Dealing with far more work than I could possibly handle and learning how to prioritize and delegate effectively

  • Managing external relationships

  • Handling budgets and numbers I would otherwise not have touched


If you are nervous about the lack of structure or mentorship, that is a real tradeoff. But you will be surprised how much you can do, and starting your own organization is also an option.


Preparing a water quality meter for measurements at a fish farm during the early FWI days. One of the unexpected skills I needed to develop was technical knowledge of water chemistry and measurement devices.
Preparing a water quality meter for measurements at a fish farm during the early FWI days. One of the unexpected skills I needed to develop was technical knowledge of water chemistry and measurement devices.

Lessons from Helping Grow FWI

When I joined, FWI had 3 staff. Today, we have 30. Below are some theories I developed about growth in a young organization.


The 7-to-10-person stage forced structure. That is when we started building more stringent systems. Our team grew with people joining from different places, so we needed a lot more structure than a small team could get away with.


People management is mostly relationship management. I didn't expect how much of the job would be managing the relationship between me and each of my direct reports, and between my direct reports: making sure people work well together, communicate well, and treat each other well. That turned out to be a much bigger task than the programmatic work. Many leaders in our movement get thrown into people management without any experience, and I was one of them.


You need a visionary and implementers. An organization needs one strong leader who sets the vision, but it also needs implementers. Knowing where everyone should sit on the bus matters for driving programs forward and keeping the organization stable.


Co-founders are gold. It is rare to find one person who is strong at implementation, at vision and creativity, and at the interpersonal side. It is hard enough to find two people who complement each other well. I watched two people do exactly that, and it made me value co-founding over founding an organization alone.


A new hire either adds work or adds capacity. In my experience, adding staff goes one of two ways. Either it creates a lot more work without adding to programming, or it adds capacity and lifts a program beyond what I envisioned for the role.


We Know Far Less Than We Think

We moved into FWI’s first year with a clear idea of what we wanted to do, and we thought we understood what needed to be done. We did not know what was ahead of us or how little we truly knew. There was no predefined welfare commitment for Indian major carp, and everything had to be generated from scratch. That was a huge undertaking, given how difficult field-based welfare research is.


Evidence generation can take years, even decades, so we shouldn't assume our field will be much faster. I don't think we, as a movement, put enough focus on it or acknowledge how hard it is.


It is also extremely challenging to find the talent needed to grow these operations, and most of our staff came from outside the movement. As the movement grows, talent pipelines will become essential to the growth of organizations like FWI.


Lessons for Funders and Organizations

My years at FWI made me reflect on the things that we as a movement require to succeed:


  • Local implementers: We need more implementers and local teams on the ground, especially in LMICs, where most of these animals live. Funders should support evidence generation and implementation by local teams equally.


  • Local programs: We need to adjust our strategies locally. For example, corporate campaigns can be very effective, but they depend on supply chains that large buyers can influence. For fishes, supply chains are often fragmented and made up of many small producers, so the work has to be built locally.


  • Comprehensive approaches: Don’t count on a “simple” commitment structure like cage-free. For Indian major carp, a more comprehensive approach, covering various welfare domains, looks necessary.


  • Evidence timelines: Plan for evidence generation to take multiple years. Other fields work on those timelines, and ours is unlikely to be much faster unless we sacrifice quality.

    • We can implement at the same time but should always keep an eye on the strength of our evidence base.


  • Stopping projects: Be ready to stop a project when the evidence says it won’t work, as we did with fortified feed, and make that easy for the team to do. Organizations should never be punished for proving that things don’t work. That is progress.


  • Talent pipelines: Build talent pipelines, especially in Asia. Most of our hires there came from global development or sustainability and didn’t see a career in animal work. We need to make the movement visible as a career.


The Team and the Community We Built in Eluru

The team in India and the wider FWI team are extraordinarily dedicated. Not just in hours, though there was a lot of weekend and evening work, and everyone was always willing to do it. This is a difficult field, and the team is extremely adept at solving hard problems on the ground. I will miss working with everyone.


ARA staff member Ravi Teja and I with some of our partner farmers at their fish farm.
ARA staff member Ravi Teja and I with some of our partner farmers at their fish farm.

They are also kind. That kindness showed up in how people treated each other, and in how we treated the beings around us: street dogs, people living on the street who needed support, other advocates, the families of our staff. People supported each other in a way I deeply appreciate.


Fishy, one of FWI’s first office dogs. Fishy always sought refuge around us, and we made sure she was well fed.
Fishy, one of FWI’s first office dogs. Fishy always sought refuge around us, and we made sure she was well fed.

FWI was also an immensely fun place to work. We lived in rural India, where there was hardly anyone else around, so we were each other's community. Our weekends included:


  • karaoke and movie nights

  • motorbike rides to pick up evening snacks

  • cooking nights and a lot of really good meals

  • weekend trips to the ocean or mountains


During a weekend hiking trip with (former) FWI team members Leroy, Teja, Vivek, and our guide (from left to right).
During a weekend hiking trip with (former) FWI team members Leroy, Teja, Vivek, and our guide (from left to right).

Why I Left and What’s Next

I loved working at FWI, and a large reason for leaving was a change in personal circumstances. Beyond that, I also believe that it is important to make space for local leadership, especially in the role of Director of Programs, so this was somewhat in the making. I am very excited to see Sakthi join our team as Programs Lead. He will live at our field office full time, something I was never able to do for more than three months at a time, and will surely help elevate our programming.


I am also eager to take these field-oriented lessons learned to the wider movement and engage with strategy beyond aquatic animals. My new role as Director of Philanthropy at Mobius allows me to do just that, and I look forward to continuing to think about how we can advance animal advocacy, particularly in LMICs.


Thank you

I want to end with a thank-you to the FWI team in India and around the world for the long hours, the care you bring to a very hard field, and your friendship. I will miss all of you dearly and look forward to seeing you again in India soon.



 
 
bottom of page